Video camera comparison – seeing is believing

There’s recently been a brief discussion on the Assocation For Learning Technologies (ALT) members discussion list, looking for opinions and recommendations of video cameras suitable for use by teaching staff and students.

I blogged on this subject a while ago, so I was interested to see how things have developed, and especially interested to see this post by Doug Belshaw from JISC InfoNET:

Date:    Tue, 13 Dec 2011 11:50:18 -0000
From:    Doug Belshaw
Subject: Re: Video Camera Recommendations

JISC Digital Media did a side-by-side comparison of the Kodak Zi8, Sony Z5 and Flip last year:

It’s definitely worth following the link and viewing the sample video (made up of clips from each camera) because it gives a rare opportunity to compare the 3 cameras side by side; it also clearly illustrates the benefits of using an external microphone with a video camera if at all possible, and shows how even a very basic budget microphone can vastly improve the soundtrack of a video recording.

A follow up message from Graham Gibbs from the University of Huddersfield highlights another video clip that compares 6 different microphones for use with video:

Date:    Sun, 18 Dec 2011 17:35:56 +0000
From:    Gibbs Graham R
Subject: Re: Video Camera Recommendations


one further post on the simple video and sound equipment issues. I’ve just come across this comparative review of 6 mics for use with the iPhone for video by Scott Skibell. I guess they would work with any other video camera with a mic socket. The mics vary from the cheapest at about £20 to £500 and you can get some idea of the quality even via the YouTube sound.


BTW for his instructional videos, Scott Skibell uses a Kodak Zi8 camera (see e.g. )

In this case the camera in question is an iPhone4S, but in principle everything said here could apply to any camera that can accept an input from an external microphone.


Invest in yourself: TechDis Tuesdays

Those  nice JISC TechDis people are running a series of 20 minute online workshops, fortnightly starting on Tuesday the 10th of January. In these sessions they plan to present a short video conversation on a specific accessibility theme, follow this with a live ‘accessibility clinic’ where you can swap stories, compare experiences and discuss good practice, then end the session with signposts to relevant resources.

    We think they are worth a look! Find out more at